chemistry-ell
Designing scalable AI prompt architectures for diverse learning contexts, from K-12 chemistry scaffolding to undergraduate research assistance. This project validates custom prompts that maximize student self-efficacy, minimize factual error, and provide equitable linguistic support across educational levels.
Chemistry ELL Content Modification Template
This template helps you modify chemistry content, such as problem sets, diagrams, and lab procedures, for English Language Learners (ELLs) based on the REACH proficiency scale. It focuses on making abstract principles and mathematical concepts accessible.
## Chemistry ELL Content Modification Template
| Section | Details |
| :--- | :--- |
| **Role** | I am a high school chemistry teacher at Chicago Public Schools. |
| **Content Area** | Chemistry |
| **Grade Level(s)** | 10th grade |
| **Learning Target** | Students will be able to balance chemical equations and identify reaction types. |
| **Success Criteria** | Students can accurately balance 5 out of 7 chemical equations and correctly classify them as synthesis, decomposition, single displacement, or double displacement reactions. |
| **Input Content (Original Question)** | "What is the law of conservation of mass and how does it relate to balancing chemical equations?" |
| **Modification Task** | Generate modified versions of the input content to support English Language Learners (ELLs) at different proficiency levels. |
| **Modification Focus** | Simplify vocabulary and syntax, use analogies and visuals, and provide clear definitions for scientific laws and processes. |
***
## Modified Content for ELL Proficiency Levels (REACH Scale)
### Level 1 (Entering)
The goal is to use **simple, high-frequency words** and focus on **concrete, visual concepts**.
**Modified Question:**
The **Law of Conservation of Mass** is a rule: The **mass** (weight) you start with must be the same as the mass you end with.
1. What is the main idea of this rule?
2. Why do we need to make the **atoms** on the left side of a chemical equation the **same** as the atoms on the right side? (We must balance the atoms.)
**Support/Scaffolding:**
* **Visual Aids:** Use a visual of a simple chemical reaction (e.g., Lego bricks) where the total number of blocks does not change, only the arrangement.
* **Sentence Frame:** "The law means the total amount of ________ doesn't change."
***
### Level 2 (Beginning)
The goal is to use **short, simple sentences** and **repeat key concepts** with a **word bank**.
**Modified Question:**
The **Law of Conservation of Mass** says: You cannot create new matter, and you cannot destroy matter. The total amount of **mass** must be the same before and after a chemical reaction.
1. Look at the word bank. What does the **Law of Conservation of Mass** tell us about matter?
2. How does this law connect to **balancing chemical equations**? (Hint: Atoms are matter.) We must count the atoms on both sides and make sure the numbers are equal.
**Word Bank:**
| Term | Simple Meaning |
| :--- | :--- |
| **Mass** | The amount of 'stuff' (weight). |
| **Conservation** | To save or keep the same. |
| **Matter** | Everything around us (atoms). |
| **Reaction** | When chemicals mix and change. |
***
### Level 3 (Developing)
The goal is to introduce **some academic vocabulary**, use **analogies**, and begin **combining ideas** in more complex structures.
**Modified Question:**
The **Law of Conservation of Mass** states that **matter** can neither be created nor destroyed in a chemical reaction. Think of it like a **recipe**: you start with a certain mass of ingredients (**reactants**), and you must end with the same total mass in the final dish (**products**).
1. Explain the Law of Conservation of Mass using your own words or the 'recipe' analogy.
2. How does this scientific law necessitate (make necessary) the process of **balancing chemical equations**?
**Support/Scaffolding:**
* **Glossary:** Provide formal definitions for *reactant* and *product*.
* **Sentence Starter:** "This law is related to balancing equations because the equation must show that the total number of atoms of each element is ________ on both sides."
***
### Level 4 (Expanding)
The goal is to use **grade-level academic vocabulary**, modify the sentence structure for **directness**, and offer **scaffolded support** for the relationship between the concepts.
**Modified Question:**
Analyze the **Law of Conservation of Mass** and articulate its direct relationship to the procedure of **balancing chemical equations**. Your explanation should clarify why the total number of atoms for each element must remain **equivalent** on both the **reactant** and **product** sides of the equation.
**Scaffolding Focus (Graphic Organizer Idea):**
| Concept | Definition | Connection to Balancing |
| :--- | :--- | :--- |
| **Law of Conservation of Mass** | (State the law) | |
| **Chemical Equation** | Shows the rearrangement of atoms | |
| **Balancing** | (Explain the process) | |
***
### Level 5 (Bridging)
The goal is to use **grade-level academic language** with minimal modification, focusing on **clarifying abstract concepts** and **significance**.
**Modified Question:**
Explain the **Law of Conservation of Mass** and discuss its **fundamental significance** in the process of **stoichiometry** and the accurate **representation** of chemical reactions through balanced equations.
**Support/Scaffolding:**
* **Focus on Significance:** Prompt students to discuss the implications of the law beyond just the mechanics of counting atoms (e.g., its role in predicting product yield or conducting quantitative analysis).
* **Vocabulary Check:** Ensure students understand high-level terms like *stoichiometry, fundamental, representation, and quantitative*.
***
### Level 6 (Reaching)
**Modified Prompt:**
**Original Question:** "What is the law of conservation of mass and how does it relate to balancing chemical equations?"
**Focus:** Minimal to no modification needed. The content is presented in its original form, focusing on **advanced scientific reasoning**. Students should be ready to independently synthesize the definition, the requirement for balancing, and the mathematical implications of the law.